Home tools Buyer's Guides from tech enthusiast who loves technology and clever solutions for better living.
Best flushable wipes 2018 – [Buyer’s Guide]Last Updated March 1, 2019
Best flushable wipes of 2018
There are dozens of choices for an flushable wipes these days. These are composed of modern styling with modern technology to match it. Here are some good examples. If you’re reading this, it is very likely that you’re scouting for the best flushable wipes. I browse the various flushable wipes available on the market and list three of the very best. I must say I am quite a fan of flushable wipes, so when the question “What are the best flushable wipes available on the market?” came to my mind, I excitedly started gathering information together with personal experience to write this article in the hope that it may help you find the suitable flushable wipes.
Test Results and Ratings
Why did this flushable wipes win the first place?
The product is very strong. Its material is stable and doesn’t crack. The rear part fits perfectly! It is mounted really tight and reliable. I don’t know anything about other models from this brand, but I am fully satisfied with this product. I am very happy with the purchase. It is definitely worth its money. The product is top-notch!
Why did this flushable wipes come in second place?
Seems that the material is good. It has a very beautiful color but I don’t really like the texture. The design quality is top notch and the color is nice. I like this product. For such a low price, I didn’t even hope it to be any better. It’s decently made. I really liked it. It is amazing in every aspect. It did even exceed my expectations for a bit, considering the affordable price.
Why did this flushable wipes take third place?
It is inconvenient to use due to the size. I am going to get something different next time. The material is incredibly nice to the touch. It has a great color, which will suit any wallpapers. I liked the design. We’ve been using it for 2 months and it still looks like brand new. This price is appropriate since the product is very well built.
flushable wipes Buyer’s Guide
Scented vs. Unscented
If your baby has a super-sensitive skin, you’ll have to avoid scented baby wipes for the sake of your baby. Babies are different and unique and some babies can’t handle perfume or fragrance around their diaper areas or anywhere near their skin. For such babies then unscented baby wipes would be the best option. On the other hand, scented baby wipes come in many varieties and the choice of a particular scented baby wipe is just a matter of personal preference. However, baby wipes that have a heavy scent or smell can also become uncomfortable to some of the parents.
Extra thick baby wipes have much material as possible between your hands and your baby’s poop to prevent the mess from leaking or soaking right through to your hands during changing time. That’s why the feel of thicker wipes is preferred by most parents as there’s no concern about any yuck soaking and leaking through the wipes and creating a mess on your hands.
FROM Agape Babies
WHAT Made of ultra-soft bamboo material, these wipes cleanse and soothe your baby’s skin with natural extracts. Since they biodegrade in just two weeks, they’ll also leave a smaller carbon footprint.
PROS Only pure, organic and natural ingredients used. Clean and natural scent.
Babies are especially vulnerable to exposures to hazardous chemicals — Given their size and the immaturity of their bodies, babies face a greater health risk from exposure to chemicals than adults. Infants breathe more air and have more skin surface per pound of body weight than adults. Because major organ systems are still developing after birth, babies do not have fully functioning metabolic systems for getting rid of toxins as efficiently as adults and can be particularly susceptible to endocrine, immune or nervous system insults. As a result, the same amount of a toxin can have a larger impact on babies than adults.
Taking precautions to avoid unnecessary exposures — Given the variety of chemical ingredients in baby products, consumers are rightly concerned about how little is known about how these chemical mixtures can affect growing infants and how lax regulatory controls are over baby products. The case for precaution is the strongest with baby products, as no mother wants to treat their baby like a guinea pig and expose them to inadequately tested chemicals.
GoodGuide separates ingredients into two categories — “ingredients of health concern” and “controversial ingredients.” Only the former contribute to a product’s rating.
A chemical must be identified as a potential health hazard by a GoodGuide-approved authoritative source (e.g., a regulatory agency like EPA or a scientific group like the National Toxicology Program) in order to be labeled an ingredient of concern.. This system ensures that our ratings are based on the best available scientific evidence. Goodguide labels chemicals as “controversial” ingredients if they have not been identified as hazardous by authoritative sources, but are the subject of current debate regarding potential adverse effects. “Controversial” chemical designations do not contribute to the product rating because the evidence of hazard is inconclusive, however they are flagged in the event a consumer wants to avoid such chemicals.
Adjustment for products that lack full ingredient data
Kleenex released the new wipes in response to consumer outrage which saw the company receive a Shonky Award in 201for claiming its Kids Cottonelle Flushable Cleansing Cloths disintegrated like toilet paper.
CHOICE made the announcement of the latest findings at the Cronulla Wastewater Treatment Plant this morning along with a Sydney Water representative who stated that a disturbing 7per cent of sewer blockages are caused by wet wipes. “Kleenex seems to have an obsession with trying to convince people to flush these products, when the fact is they can clog up your pipes and can be rough on your wallet,” says CHOICE Head of Media Tom Godfrey. “Although the new wipes disintegrated more than the old wipes, they didn’t break down fast enough and we believe they pose a blockage threat particularly in the first several metres of pipe on the consumer’s property.
At least 7per cent of sewer blockages are caused by wet wipes.
New product still poses problems “With consumers, local councils and water services organisations struggling with the cost of removing ‘fatbergs’ from the sewage system, it’s encouraging Kleenex is trying to clean up its act but this new product still poses problems,” Tom says.
A petition is calling on all manufacturers and retailers to remove misleading claims that the wipes are in fact flushable.
Why you should listen to us
I wrote the original version of this guide in early 2013, spending about 20 hours reading and researching the category. Since then, I have written guides to paper towels and facial tissues, learning a great deal about the paper manufacturing industry, recycling, and how paper products work and break apart. For what it’s worth, I also researched and wrote a guide to The Best Toilet Brush.
For this update, I put another 20 hours into researching a much wider array of brands and varieties. I interviewed Kenn Fischburg, owner of Consumers Interstate Corporation and author of The Toilet Paper Encyclopedia, patient blogger Duncan Cross, and a representative with emergency plumbing firm 91Restoration. I also tested samples myself, along with soliciting people—half Wirecutter staffers, half outside testers—to try our top contenders.
Flaws but not dealbreakers
Squares of Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Care do not always rip cleanly off the roll. If you know yourself well enough to know you like a clean tear-off with every visit, go with our runner-up, Charmin Ultra Strong, which deserves a gold medal in sheet-tearing.
While we found packages of Ultra Comfort Care at many stores, it was not as easily available as Charmin Ultra Strong, which we could find at nearly every grocery and drug store in our area.
It’s not a budget toilet paper; you can get Kirkland Signature, Scott Naturals Tube-Free, or Seventh Generation for half the price. But it’s less expensive than ultra-premium brands like Quilted Northern Ultra Plush, and Charmin’s Ultra Soft and Ultra Strong brands. It also performs a good deal better than many papers that cost more.
We found Charmin Ultra Strong to have notably less cleaning power, slightly less softness, and a very slightly higher likelihood to lint than our top pick. Charmin Ultra Strong also had less wet strength, men in our testing panel found, but women found it about even. Notably, though, we found Charmin Ultra Strong to be far more absorptive than other brands, stronger than our panel believed, the best at tearing cleanly off its roll, and more widely available than our top pick.
Charmin Ultra Strong held about 13.times its dry weight in water in our testing, a bit more than Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Care (see chart above). Most important, its sheets held together while dunked, removed, and carried over to the scale. Being able to retain moisture without falling apart is a key job for toilet paper, so that it doesn’t leave wet remnants, and you don’t end up using a toilet-clogging amount for tougher bathroom visits. The only other brands near Charmin Ultra Strong’s wet-to-dry ratio were our pick, Scott Naturals Tube-Free, which fell apart entirely when picked up, and Charmin Basic, our budget pick, detailed further below.
When sheets are pulled from rolls, Charmin Ultra Strong does the best. It tore right on its perforated line 1out of 20 times, and the two not-perfect rips resulted in very minor inward tears of less than an inch. Only Charmin Basic, our budget pick, came close to the Ultra Strong’s perfect tearing.
The cheaper stock-up option
Charmin Basic provides better softness and cleaning power than you’d expect for its very reasonable price, but it’s not as soft and doesn’t absorb as well as our other picks.
Our panelists thought the Charmin Basic was one of the softer papers; it’s not as soft as the Cottonelle Ultra Comfort Care, but it easily beat the cheaper papers (like Kirkland Signature or Scott 1000). It fell somewhere in the middle of the pack in our panel’s wet-strength ratings (averaging 3.out of 5), but we found it held almost as much water as our top pick while staying together. It tied with Charmin Ultra Strong on cleaning power in our panelists’ ratings, and while it didn’t come close to Charmin Ultra Strong’s absorption, it did nearly tie our Cottonelle pick.
Charmin Basic’s primary weakness is its linting. It’s surprisingly fluffy for a one-ply paper, and strong, but when it does break apart, it can leave some lint. I didn’t find it as lint-prone as ultra-plush brands like Quilted Northern or Scott Extra Soft in my testing, but our panelists put it last out of nine brands, with a 3.average rating out of (the top brand garnered a 4.25).
Don’t buy wipes, unless you’re willing to put your used wipes in your bathroom trash can, or maintain a separate can for them.
Don’t buy wipes, unless you’re willing to put your used wipes in your bathroom trash can, or maintain a separate can for them. Flushing them down your toilet is passing along a huge problem to your sewer system, as evidenced by sewer crises in New York City, London, and recurring problems in Miami, Louisiana, Ottawa, and almost any other city where someone interviews a local sewer systems manager. Unless you’re willing to spare the effort, and you’ve made peace with using twice as much paper and binding products, wipes probably aren’t worth it for your bathroom.
Scott Extra Soft was highly ranked by Consumer Reports, seemingly for its disintegration and tearing ease. Our panel ranked it as the absolute softest (4.out of 5), but only middle of the road (3.6) for cleaning power and linting. It might make a good budget option (at 1.5¢ per square foot) for those who value softness above all else.
White Cloud Ultra Soft & Thick was our prior pick for the best toilet paper, and it likely still would be, were it available for purchase anywhere other than retail Walmart stores. The same general dismissal goes for most store brands, with one exception: Kirkland Signature, from Costco.
Kirkland Signature earned high marks from our panel in softness, wet strength, and cleaning power, but absorbed the least out of any toilet paper we tested. We also saw a few squares break into wet, rolled-up pieces when it was handled while wet.
Scott Naturals Tube-Free earned the lowest ratings our panel gave out in softness (averaging out of 5) and cleaning power (2.75), and earned second-to-last place in linting and wet strength. It absorbed the second-most liquid, but paradoxically fell apart during testing.
Charmin Ultra Soft was not ultra-soft, or ultra-anything to our panelists. It averaged a out of in softness, just above in wet strength and cleaning power. It didn’t lint, but it costs nearly the same as Charmin Ultra Strong and is not as good.
Quilted Northern Ultra Plush is a pillowy soft three-ply paper that fell in the middle of the pack for softness, strength, and cleaning power with our panel, but near the bottom in linting. It absorbs 3percent less than Ultra Strong, and we found it to have significantly less cleaning power.
Cottonelle Clean Care did very poorly when tested for absorption, coming apart in wet strands when moved from water to scale, and also ripped clean only about half the time we pulled it off the roll. It was ranked second to last in softness by our panel.
LADYGROOMER Woman Wipes
LADYGROOMER Woman Wipes is suitable for those with sensitive skin since it lacks parabens and alcohol, and it is hypoallergenic. Despite the pretty packaging, these wipes get the job done. They help you clean up easy during your moment of need, leaving you with that refreshed and cool feel. Buying these wipes is considered as an investment for those who use a lot of wipes since they are in bulk.
Item Weight: 2.ounces
These body wipes boast a discreet packaging which makes them excellent for daily use. They’re ideal for various activities and can be used on all body parts without any harm whatsoever. They neutralize body sweat thus keeping one feeling fresh and smelling awesome. And yes, they’re flushable which means that you won’t be having issues with disposal at all. And, of course, they’re fragrance free thus can be used by those who have allergies and fragrance intolerances.
Just like other summer’s Eve products, the cleansing cloths gets the job done. The wipes are infused with vitamin E and aloe that allow them to be as gentle as they can be on skin. They are also parabens and alcohol free, all advantages for those with sensitive skin. These wipes are packed in dispenser packs with 3clothes in each, making them convenient for long journeys but that really isn’t the case for those who only need a few when going to and fro from work or school, since they need less than 3As expected, the end result after use is that cool and refreshing feel, not forgetting the lovely scent.
Ingredients: This should be the most important factor to consider. Most wipe companies claim that their product is chemical free and 100% safe for use whereas it’s not always the case. You should always confirm that the ingredients used in your desired wipes will not cause any complications to your system unless you want to invite an infection rather than prevent it. Some of the potentially irritant and harmful ingredients to steer clear from include alcohol, glycerin and acetate among others.
Size: Although this should come without saying, the size of the wipes matter. Even though small wipes might easily fit into your purse, they become a challenge since they cannot be used on a wide surface whereas larger wipes can. Small wipes are therefore more suitable for petite ladies and large wipes for any size. Of course, the size also affects portability and performance. Unless you want to take a flop home, ensure that you pick nice feminine wipes.
Scent: Some ladies are more sensitive to scented products than others. Before you purchase any set of wipes, it’s best to establish whether they are scented or unscented, just to avoid any unnecessary disappointments once you want to use them. Specialists however always advise on unscented wipes since some fragrances cause irritation and discomfort when in contact with the vaginal area.
Durability: I’m almost certain that no one wants a product that needs to be constantly reused for the desired effect. Those type of wipes run out easily and you find yourself running back and forth from the mall to get more. This is a waste of both time and money. It’s therefore best to ensure that the wipes you have chosen have a long lasting effect, proving convenient to use.Unless you want to keep frequenting the market every now and then, ensure that you pick something durable. Of course, it’s challenging to determine whether any item is durable or not before using it. However, you need to make an attempt of enquiring or outsourcing information concerning durability from secondary sources.
Method of Disposal: Some feminine wipes are flushable while some are not. You might be in an area where the sanitation bins aren’t easily available and in this case you would prefer the flushable wipes that erase your fear of blocking the toilet’s drainage system. Method of disposable is an important aspect, especially for convenience purposes. Do not just grab any feminine wipes you see around, just go for the pick of the bunch.
Wonderland Pumping Station
Home to more than 380,000 people, the growing City of London is located just north of Lake Erie and the United States border. The city operates six wastewater treatment plants that are located along the Thames River and 3pumping stations throughout the city.
The Wonderland Pumping Station, constructed in 20and located on Dingman Road, is one of the largest stations by volume in the City of London, with a rated capacity of 45,500 cu m/day. The station includes two grinders for influent sewage and four 160-KW, 320-L/second submersible pumps installed in separate wet wells, with each pump discharging through a 400-mm pipe to a common 750-mm header. All pumps are controlled by variable frequency drives. The header is connected to a 750-mm PVC force main that discharges approximately km northeast of the station.
Grinders Built for Wipes
The rag balls would then slow or completely clog sewer pumps. The JWC research team found that strips of wipes would rope together in the swirling action of a sewer system. To prevent this, the redesigned Wipes Ready Channel Monster and Muffin Monster models use new cutters, screening drums and operating technologies to improve debris capture rate and cut wipes into smaller pieces. Testing showed that these enhancements eliminated the formation of long strips and rag balls in test environments.
Looking for solutions and new technologies to improve the situation, city staff discussed the maintenance and clogging issues with both JWC Environmental and Envirocan. Both companies saw this as a perfect opportunity to put the new Wipes Ready technologies to the test.
In mid-2015, JWC outfitted one of the new Wipes Ready Channel Monsters at the Wonderland Pumping Station. This model incorporates full Wipes Ready features, including 17-tooth serrated cutters and knurled spacers, as well as optimum cut-control gearing. The grinder already had perforated screening drums, which remained in place.
The dual-shafted design of the Channel Monster grinder easily shreds through rags, clothing, wood and rocks, turning them into tiny, manageable particles that pass through pipes and pumps without clogging the equipment or compromising flow. The inline units also quickly adapt into existing pipelines, saving on installation time.
The upgrade to a grinder designed for the wipes problems at the Wonderland Pump Station allowed the city to greatly reduce maintenance time and costs. Operations and maintenance department staffers were also happy that JWC took the time to listen to and help resolve their issues. The significant cost savings, coupled with eliminating the need for operators to manually de-rag the pumps on a nearly daily basis, made this project a success.
Think before you flush.
Wet wipes that increasing numbers of New Yorkers are using instead of toilet paper are clogging the city’s sewer system — and now the City Council is mulling a crackdown.
Unlike toilet paper, which disintegrates quickly once it enters the sewer system, the wet wipes stay intact and pile up on screens at wastewater treatment plants, where they have to be removed.
Plus, the wipes get caught in pumps and gears and cause jams, Sapienza said. He said the department supports the idea of banning “flushable” marketing, though officials have to review the specific language of the bill.
Purchasing in Bulk
Just like a good number of consumable baby products, the more baby wipes you purchase; the cheaper the cost.
Online stores and a few brick and mortar stores currently deliver baby products including baby wipes. This gives you an option of buying bulk packages of wipes, frequently at reduced cost and the nicest thing is that you will have it delivered at your doorstep.
Flushable wipes are commonly aimed at toddlers who are being potty-trained but may be essential for you if you make use of hybrid diaper systems with flushable inserts. These wipes frequently come in a plastic flip-top box, much like the standard baby wipes.
Sometimes, you can get its refill packs. You must be careful not to flush too many wipes at a time. If your septic system get’s blocked, you could end up paying expensive plumbing bill.
How do you know if the wipes and other products you’re using are flushable? The simplest answer comes from Cynthia Finley, director of regulatory affairs for the National Association of Clean Water Agencies, which represents wastewater utilities in Washington, D.C. “Until we are sure that all wipes that are labeled as “flushable” are truly safe for the sewer system, it is best to throw them (all) away in a trash can,” she said.
Don Wasko, who runs the wastewater system in Carlsbad, Calif., put it even more simply.
Individual sheets vs bulk packages
Most wet wipes come in bulk packages, with 10-30 wipes inside one container. Others came individually wrapped in pouches about the size of a credit card or postcard.
You would assume that individually wrapped sheets would take up more overall space than wipes in a single package. But we found in practice that the individually wrapped sheets are usually bigger and more robust. You can clean more of yourself with just one sheet, which means a multi-pack of 30 sheets might be the same “space value” as individually wrapped ones.
As we conducted these tests, all of the reviewers agreed that the individually wrapped wipes were very nice for bug out and get home bags. It’s easy and natural to fit them in all of the little space gaps and pockets that are hardly used anyway.
Although less space efficient overall, individual packets can fit in those unused BOB gaps.
Although not a huge deal, we preferred wipes that you could easily pull out one at a time. Many of the bulk packages fold one sheet into the other, like standard tissues, so that when you pull one out the next one is pulled along with it.
We find this annoying in the field because the convenience is not worth the hassle of a crumbled corner being pulled out that you have to push back in with your fingers, trying to get it to lay flat again so you can properly close the seal.
There are popular products that come in larger packages, holding 50 to 300 wipes. They are meant for sitting on a shelf next to a baby changing table or toilet, so we disqualified these when shopping because we felt portability is important.
Example of a hard plastic closure.
We thought the hard plastic snap closures might unintentionally flip open when tossed around in a bag full of gear. But we saw no issues after testing them in a full bug out bag and a full purse.
There was a wide variety in how manufacturers handled this part. The wipes that are marketed towards field use tended to have a more robust construction, with thicker plastic and hinge points, which made a big difference in how well they held up to abuse.
We would hold the package in one hand and open the flap with the other with normal force and speed. Tears would often happen towards the hinge at the top opening hole or along the side. Although some rips were clean enough where you could carefully put the flap back down and create an effective seal, for survival use we thought this was pretty unacceptable.
A big bulky package that is soft and can be crushed is less ideal inside an emergency bag, especially with excess liquid inside the pouch that can leak out.
Feminine hygiene and bathroom test
Unfortunately, our imperfect human meat-bags tend to need the most cleaning in the areas that are also the most sensitive. So it was important to test if these wipes were effective on every part of the body.
We thought about three scenarios: after defecating for men and women, after female urination, and during female menstruation.
There are products specifically marketed for toilet use, like the Goodwipes Down There flushable wipes. In the end, we didn’t see enough of a difference between “body” wipes and “genital” wipes to affect our recommendation for most people.
However, if you have medical needs (like a pH imbalance) or have the extra space in your home supplies storage, feel free to supplement the main body wipes with whatever works for you. There are reports of people having vaginal or anal reactions to wipes, particularly those with the chemical MCI.
After using each wipe in each scenario, we paid attention to any stinging or discomfort in addition to how well they worked. We didn’t find any difference in how well they worked compared to other parts of the body, but we did notice a difference in comfort between wipes.
Daily shower test
We did a practical test using an adult man and woman for three weeks to test how easy and effective each wipe was.
To keep things fair, we used one wipe per day at the same time, right before taking a normal shower with normal soap. Which meant each test was done after about 2hours of normal build up with relatively consistent conditions. We excluded any days where we had an unusual amount of physical activity or dirtiness.
There was a noticeable difference in how well some sheets would move across skin. Some of the wipes would quickly fray or the edges would roll up in your hand as you moved, creating a balled bunch you had to stop and uncurl. Which was quite frustrating when trying to do a full body wipe down.
Some wipes were quick to twist and curl up on themselves during use. Very annoying.
ALDI Australia has pulled its plans to sell a flushable wipes product after the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (ACCC) and shoppers raised concerns.
An ALDI spokesperson told News Corp the company was working with the ACCC and apologised for inconvenience to customers.
While our discussions with the ACCC continue, we have decided not to sell this product.
In a statement sent to News Corp Australia, an ACCC spokesman said that it had raised concerns with ALDI about the product earlier this week.
First of all thanks for reading my article to the end! I hope you find my reviews listed here useful and that it allows you to make a proper comparison of what is best to fit your needs and budget. Don’t be afraid to try more than one product if your first pick doesn’t do the trick.
Most important, have fun and choose your flushable wipes wisely! Good luck!
So, TOP3 of flushable wipes
- №1 — DUDE Wipes Flushable Wet Wipes
- №2 — Care Touch Flushable Personal Wipes for Men and Women
- №3 — Cottonelle FreshCare Flushable Wipes